'Star Wars': We Have to Collectively Resolve Whether or not JJ Abrams Is the Darkish Facet or A New Hope for 'Episode IX'

So the place does that go away Abrams on this complete narrative? The studio clearly trusts him, after he efficiently rebooted the franchise in 2015, and stayed on as an govt producer for the upcoming Star Wars Episode VIII: The Final Jedi — in theaters on Dec. 15 — however when the 51-year-old filmmaker ignites his proverbial lightsaber of artistic management, is that factor lighting up pink or blue?

Let’s attempt to collectively resolve that proper now. Not with the Drive or planet-destroying lasers, however with a professional/con record.

CON: J.J. Abrams is a “secure” alternative.

Clearly, the addition of Abrams to the image brings with it the criticisms some had after he revived the franchise with The Drive Awakens — specifically, that it was a $300 million focus-grouped remake of A New Hope (extra on this in a bit). It’s value noting that this was removed from the consensus of opinion. Episode VII nonetheless enjoys comparatively common acclaim, and is even “Licensed Recent” on Rotten Tomatoes, sitting nominally larger than Rogue One: A Star Wars Story — the franchise’s first non-Skywalker saga film, which supplied a brand new perspective within the battle between the Empire and the insurgent alliance — each in general rating and common ranking.

Even so, administrators usually go away their particular mark on a mission, and should you had been excited to see what Trevorrow (Jurassic World, Security Not Assured) may deliver to the Star Wars you understand and love, this transfer has to take a little bit of oomph out of your pleasure. With Abrams, you understand what you’re getting — and also you in all probability already know whether or not you assume that’s good or dangerous.

PRO: Not so quick on the “secure” factor.

Let’s not overlook Abrams’ new period of Star Wars bucked the long-standing roster of white, male leads, that includes Daisy Ridley and John Boyega of their breakout roles, together with Guatemalan-American actor Oscar Isaac, who rounded out the primary forged of heroes.

That is essential, as a result of even with all of the dialog that’s occurred not too long ago concerning Hollywood’s want to deal with its range downside, we’re lower than three years faraway from Boyega having to defend stormtrooper could be black.

Regardless of his deep respect for the unique trilogy, it isn’t precisely honest to imagine that Abrams gained’t attempt to break much more floor with the upcoming movie.

CON:The Drive Awakens felt like a reboot of Episode IV.

*Drive Awakens spoilers right here*

Right here’s the deal: The individuals who felt like The Drive Awakens tracked just a little too intently to A New Hope kinda had a degree.

Even should you purchase that the many-planet destroying Starkiller Base is totally different sufficient from the single-planet destroying Loss of life Star, beat for beat, the 2 films — each the primary of their trilogies — run parallel in lots of methods.

You’ve received the entire galaxy on the hunt for an cute little droid holding onto some completely essential info, Rey because the desert dweller-turned hero a la Luke Skywalker and a largely unchanged construction for the Empire’s chain of command (to not point out Kylo Ren, who even appears like Darth Vader), which by some means has not realized to not go away your weapons of planetary destruction weak to trench assault by way of insurgent plane.

It’s totally attainable that The Drive Awakens was only a jumping-off level, and The Final Jedi will take us in thrilling new instructions. But when the Rian Johnson-directed sequel looks like The Empire Strikes Again: Redux, we could also be in for a really acquainted Episode IX.

PRO: Regardless of the similarities, The Drive Awakens stands by itself.

Followers will argue that Abrams made primarily essentially the most intelligent reboot to a franchise of all time, the place should you weren’t on the lookout for it, you in all probability didn’t even discover it’s a reboot.

And from what we realized thus far, it actually doesn’t really feel like Johnson is rebooting Empire Strikes Again. Plus, whereas he isn’t within the director’s chair, Abrams is govt producing Episode VIII, so he’s very concerned with the method and subsequently is aware of what’s happening. So earlier than we get anxious about what he’ll do with Episode IX, let’s wait and see what The Final Jedi has in retailer.

CON:  Let’s discuss artistic range.

Regardless of its numerous slate of stars, which continues with Kelly Marie Tran’s casting in The Final Jedi, Lucasfilm has not made any non-white male selections when it comes to administrators. That is true. We’ve received Abrams, Gareth Edwards (and type of Tony Gilroy), Johnson, Phil Lord and Chris Miller, Ron Howard, Colin Trevorrow, possibly Josh Trank and now Abrams once more.

To be honest, the rumor mill continuously throws administrators like Ava DuVernay and Patty Jenkins within the combine, although neither of them have ever been formally tapped for a Star Wars function. Range within the director’s chair is a much bigger downside than this franchise, however at this level, solely white dudes have directed Star Wars — and that should change, sooner reasonably than later.

PRO: J.J. Abrams is aware of and created these new characters.

That is the largest argument for why Abrams is the proper individual to deliver this trilogy full circle.

If we’re actually anxious concerning the reshoots and revolving door of administrators, who higher to take the lead and produce us house than the man who kicked issues off within the first place? It saved the Quick & Livid franchise. Who’s to say it may well’t work for the world’s best area opera too?

On the danger of belaboring the purpose, it bears repeating: With Abrams, you understand what you’re getting. And that’s not all the time a foul factor. Isn’t that one of many issues we hated concerning the prequels?  Lucas’ unchecked imaginative and prescient introducing complicated new ideas and characters to the story we all know and love? If nothing else, Abrams deserves the prospect to totally ship on the imaginative and prescient of Star Wars that Lucasfilm appears to not solely endorse, however wholly adheres to.

PRO: This can be a probability to deliver again Constable Zuvio.

We haven’t forgotten about you, Constable. We’ve nonetheless received your motion determine, and are eagerly awaiting so that you can make your heroic debut.

VERDICT: Over right here, a minimum of, we’re giving Abrams the good thing about the doubt. You’re our Jedi, J.J. Please don’t go all Anakin on us.

log in

reset password

Back to
log in